websherpa
Active Member
I think things have been changing in the past few years at the border, especially with the emphasis on it being a sales tax making prospect for the feds. And now with the Internet, the guards can do some easy research to try to determine an arbitrary value, despite what you say, or what it says on a receipt.
I think that's more the issue here. Having a receipt from a US Walmart is one thing. Buying used goods is quite another.
A used machine lists at a certain arbitrary value (above, below or at "market" rate) and usually on used goods you negotiate a lower price. So you come prepared and have the seller sign a receipt (for the actual amount paid) and put their contact info on the receipt for direct corroboration... and STILL some people get hassled and the CBS points to some recent asking prices online on eBay (which are always inflated) or even the original sales ad (or so I have heard).
What can one do but pay the tax on the arbitrarily assigned value (hoping that it's not far above what was really paid) and then, one supposes, file a grievance with evidence to effect a refund, not!
I do think, though, based on some of the stories declared in these forums, that some cross-border shoppers are more regularly hassled than others.
I think that's more the issue here. Having a receipt from a US Walmart is one thing. Buying used goods is quite another.
A used machine lists at a certain arbitrary value (above, below or at "market" rate) and usually on used goods you negotiate a lower price. So you come prepared and have the seller sign a receipt (for the actual amount paid) and put their contact info on the receipt for direct corroboration... and STILL some people get hassled and the CBS points to some recent asking prices online on eBay (which are always inflated) or even the original sales ad (or so I have heard).
What can one do but pay the tax on the arbitrarily assigned value (hoping that it's not far above what was really paid) and then, one supposes, file a grievance with evidence to effect a refund, not!
I do think, though, based on some of the stories declared in these forums, that some cross-border shoppers are more regularly hassled than others.