Just wanted to follow up and help wrap up this thread.
Unfortunately, it seems that there wasn't a whole lot of response to this game.
I received a call from the owner last week and was told I could have it.
With some great help from our own resident blogger, this 1960 Williams Deluxe Official Baseball has found a new home. Even with some of the reels not working, we managed to set it up and have a quick game. It was set for 3 innings and there were just enough working indicator bulbs that we managed to have a pretty decent game. We just had to count runs in our heads for player two.
Thanks Rob!
I still say it was a tie, but I guess we'll never know
Anyway, I'll be digging into it over the next few days and see if I can get it running 100% before I dig in for a proper restore.