$6K
This game has a few potentially high dollar mods too. If it has an LCD hologram, lit speaker panel and so on you might be looking at more
This sounds about right and I paid $4800 for mine back in Nov 2014 and added the MikeD LCD hologram mod. Be careful because just like WH20 repro parts for creech such as ramps and plastics can add up very fast. Also check the ball drop on the in lanes especially the right one because it takes a beating. Mine were pretty beat and I had Drano help me make some decals to go over top of the worn wood and put mylar to protect them.
I'm kicking myself because early on I passed on a few very nice ones back in 2011-2013 for $3000-3200. I know Creech can be a very polarizing game and people either love it or hate. When I looked at pictures of it on ipdb it looked very clustered sorta like Indiana Jones which is a game I am not a fan of. But after playing budfan's Creech a few years back I feel in love with it right away and had to have one. I should have known because I typically enjoy most of Trudeau's games. The theme does nothing for me but I don't mind it because it helps create a very campy atmosphere.
Contrary to meegis above, I can't see myself parting with my Creech for a Metallica but then again most who know me will probably know that I wouldn't part a Bally/Williams for a Stern either
I would advise you go spend some more time playing Creech before you make any sort of trade with your Metallica. The good news is you can still find another nice Metallica down the road should you have any sort of regrets.