Thanks for the tips!
There's a Benjamin Moore near me. Didn't event think to look there.
I'm actually going there tomorrow to see what they have in the way of tinted fillers. I know that larger RONA stores will likely stock the Circa 1850 but I have not been able to get over to the biggest one near me yet.
Truth is, most of the trim is in awesome shape, but these siderails are pretty rough and will never look great
I'll manage though.
The Williams logos are not 'technically' available.
Let's just say it was a gift.
I also know of a couple of sources for the 3D logo plates that appeared on pitch and bat games prior to Official Baseball. As near as I can tell, this is the game where they switched to screened logos instead of plates... And they're almost always worn off.
I own a 1959 Pinch Hitter, which I think is the pitch and bat game Williams made just before this one (although they made several pinball machines in-between). It has the 3D version badge. Also, Official Baseball promo flyers showed the older 3D style logo badge but almost all had the screened logo on the door. Now, I have seen a couple of examples with coin doors showing the two bolt holes (indicating they originally had badges), but this is rare. So, my guess is they probably used up what they had at the factory and then completed the bulk of the run with the new doors with silkscreened logos.
There... That was sufficiently boring. My apologies
Hope you enjoy pinball history.